top of page

Contentious Politics in Spain: Balancing Autonomy, Democracy, and Monarchy

The emergence of conservative political parties in Spain, notably VOX, whose agenda prioritizes the defense of the monarchy's authority and implementing policies to restrict the autonomy of individual communities across Spain, responds to movements for independence and migration challenges.

 

VOX, Spain
The prominent display of the VOX flag symbolizes the recent ascent and push for power of the far-right and nationalist political party in Spain.
Contentious Politics in Spain

Contentious politics refers to the processes by which individuals and groups engage in political actions to express grievances, advance interests, or challenge authorities. These actions often involve contentious tactics such as protests, strikes, demonstrations, and other forms of collective action to influence political outcomes. Contentious politics may allude to collective actions or behaviors by groups or individuals aimed at making claims about and changing the existing political, social, or economic order.


In recent decades, protests have arisen in Catalonia as its citizens fight for democracy and independence from Spanish rule under the parliament and monarchy.

In recent years, Spain has witnessed significant contentious politics surrounding protests against the monarchy and demands for self-autonomy, particularly in regions like Catalonia. Demonstrations have resulted in direct criticism directed at Catalan citizens from the royal monarch, King Felipe VI. Despite the concentration of conservative political groups and parties in Spain, their response to these challenges has been complex.


On the one hand, conservative groups have often defended the monarchy as a symbol of national unity and stability, advocating for its preservation amidst growing dissent, viewing any challenges to it as a threat to Spanish nationalism. This sentiment stems from the Spanish Civil War in the 1930s and the subsequent Franco dictatorship era, during which the conservative leader Franco abolished the Spanish monarchy. Such views align with their broader agenda of upholding traditional institutions and values in government and policy decisions. On the other hand, conservative groups have also demonstrated varying willingness to engage with demands for self-autonomy, particularly in Catalonia. As Spain confronts contentious political issues, the emergence of parties like VOX introduces a new element to the country's political scene.


Far-Right VOX in Spain

VOX is a Spanish political party known for its right-wing populist and nationalist ideology. It advocates for policies aligned with neoliberalism, emphasizing free-market principles, deregulation, and limited government intervention in the economy. Additionally, VOX has been criticized for its promotion of nationalist and authoritarian tendencies, which some observers associate with fascist ideologies. The party's stance on various issues, including immigration, cultural identity, and regional autonomy, reflects its populist and nationalist agenda. VOX got its name in Spain as an acronym derived from the Latin word "vōx," meaning "voice," similar to the Spanish word "voz." It was chosen to symbolize their mission of giving voice to the concerns and values of the Spanish people.


A supporter of far-right policies waves an unconventional Spanish flag alongside the conservative VOX party flag.

As VOX has gained popularity, it has raised concerns among Spaniards and the international community due to various factors deeply ingrained in the country's recent and historical past. The political party's adoption of nationalist rhetoric and its firm opposition to regional autonomy movements, particularly in Catalonia and the Basque Country, evokes memories of Spain's authoritarian Francoist regime. If VOX had won the 2023 general elections, it would have been the first far-right party to govern Spain since the Franco dictatorship. This period of authoritarian control, characterized by the suppression of regional identities and centralized power, not only restrained regional autonomy but also saw the suppression of local languages such as Catalan, Valencian, Basque, Galician, and other languages across Spain. This policy aimed to enforce Castilian Spanish as the dominant language and further centralize power under the Franco regime.


Furthermore, VOX's populist discourse, which often targets immigrants, Muslims, and other minority groups, provokes worries regarding the protection of human rights. Like many European countries, Spain has experienced an increase in nationalist and anti-immigrant sentiments in the aftermath of the COVID-19 pandemic, economic crises associated with inflation, and waves of migration, as a country of immigration. The rise of VOX reflects and amplifies these sentiments, contributing to polarization and social tensions within Spanish society. Internationally, it is part of the broader trend of far-right populism across Europe, raising concerns about the potential destabilization of democratic norms and institutions. Many observers have characterized such policies as neo-fascist, mainly due to their exclusionary stance towards minorities in the country.


Protesters strongly support a 'Unified Spain' under a far-right government's leadership.

The rise in popularity of VOX is intricately linked with Spain's historical legacy and the current socio-political environment. While concerns about the party's rhetoric and policies echo memories of Spain's Francoist past, they also mirror broader anxieties about the direction of democracy and the resurgence of far-right movements in Europe. As such, the rise of VOX emphasizes the importance of vigilance in protecting democratic values and promoting social inclusion in Spain and beyond.


Migration and the Far-Right Agenda

Andalusia, an autonomous community and region in southern Spain, has experienced significant migration-related challenges, including irregular migration flows, refugee arrivals, and integration issues. These challenges have sparked debates and controversies regarding immigration policies, border controls, humanitarian assistance, and social cohesion. Andalusia's geographical location as a gateway between Europe and Africa makes it particularly vulnerable to migration pressures, underlining the need for thorough and synchronized responses at the regional, national, and international levels. Additionally, the Spanish autonomous cities of Ceuta and Melilla, situated on the northern coast of Morocco, serve as crucial entry points for migrants from countries across Africa seeking entry into Europe, further highlighting the intricate nature of migration in the region. Moreover, migration challenges intertwine with debates over regional autonomy, particularly noticeable in Catalonia's ongoing interest in independence.


A protester against migration holds up a sign reading "Stop invasion!", highlighting concerns regarding the migration crisis in Spain.

The issues surrounding migration in Andalusia intersect with the concerns raised by the recent emergence of far-right politics. Strict border controls and anti-immigrant resentment are central policy interests of the VOX party and its supporters. Segments of the population are concerned about the impact of migration on social cohesion and economic stability, viewing migrants as outsiders and a threat to culture and national identity. Furthermore, VOX's approach to immigration has been criticized for its nationalist rhetoric and lack of consideration for humanitarian concerns.


The emergence of far-right ideologies in Spain has further complicated efforts to address migration challenges in Andalusia and other regions. While some advocate for stricter immigration policies to preserve national identity and security, others emphasize the importance of upholding human rights and supporting migrants in need. This perspective contrast reflects broader debates over the role of nationalism, multiculturalism, and globalization in shaping national and regional policies and culture in Spain.


As Andalusia and other Autonomous Communities in Spain grapple with the complexities of migration and regional autonomy, it becomes increasingly crucial for Spanish citizens to raise awareness and promote constructive discourse. It is essential to seek solutions that balance the interests of different stakeholders to prevent a political divide among citizens. This includes addressing underlying socioeconomic factors driving migration through diplomatic dialogue between leaders in other countries, enhancing integration efforts, and fostering greater cooperation between regional and national authorities. By addressing migration challenges comprehensively and inclusively, Autonomous Communities can mitigate the risks posed by far-right ideologies and promote a more inclusive and resilient society.


Map of the Spain highlighting its 17 Autonomous Communities, each represented by their respective flags.
Autonomous Communities of Spain

Catalonia, along with the other sixteen Autonomous Communities in Spain, enjoys a degree of self-governance and autonomy under the Spanish Constitution of 1978. This autonomy, in contrast to the centralized control of the Franco era, grants regions across the country certain powers over education, healthcare, culture, and language. However, tensions between the central government and regional authorities, especially in Catalonia, have recently escalated due to disputes over independence, fiscal distribution, cultural identity, and language rights. Catalonia's independence has become a contentious political issue, leading to political polarization and calls for greater autonomy or even secession from Spain.


Under the Royal Crown, Despite the Democracy

Francisco Franco, the far-right, conservative, and fascist dictator of Spain

During the Franco dictatorship, which lasted from the collapse of the Spanish Second Republic in 1939 until Francisco Franco's passing and Spain's eventual return to democracy in 1979, the monarchy was abolished. Franco, a conservative Spanish military general, led the Nationalist forces that overthrew the Second Spanish Republic during the Spanish Civil War of the 1930s. Throughout his authoritarian rule, characterized by Francoism, he strongly opposed democracy in Spain.

Since the fall of the dictatorship under Franco, Spain has maintained a democratic and progressive political atmosphere. Consequently, the emergence of far-right politics in the country is a source of concern for both the Spanish population and the international community. Despite Spain's authoritarian, far-right past, recent developments have witnessed the rise of far-right movements, drawing critical attention to their nationalist and conservative ideologies and their potential implications for the country's future direction.


King Felipe VI and Queen Letizia of Spain

Spanish politicians supportive of far-right ideologies may significantly influence policies in the country, particularly in the context of the monarchy. The far-right nationalist rhetoric and opposition to regional autonomy movements can potentially undermine efforts to foster social cohesion and regional convergence. Given Spain's constitutional monarchy, where the King acts as a unifying symbol, conservative positions may introduce challenges to maintaining national unity and solidarity, especially in regions with strong regional identities such as Catalonia and the Basque Country. This could escalate tensions and impede progress in addressing regional disparities. As per the Spanish Constitution, King Felipe VI assumes the roles of head of state and commander-in-chief of the Spanish Armed Forces, holding the military title of Captain General. Additionally, he serves as Spain's primary representative in international diplomacy and relations.


Furthermore, conservative populist discourse, which often targets minority groups, may contribute to social polarization and hinder efforts to promote inclusive development. In a country striving for balanced growth and territorial cohesion, the rise of a conservative agenda could lead to policy decisions that prioritize certain regions over others, potentially exacerbating existing inequalities. Moreover, the far-right's opposition to immigration and multiculturalism could impact Spain's ability to attract foreign talent and investment, essential for economic growth and innovation.


In this context, contentious politics could significantly challenge regional development processes across Spain. The push and pull factors influencing the spatial distribution of development may be further complicated by political debates and social unrest fueled by the presence of far-right policy agendas. Contentious politics could impede consensus-building and decision-making, making implementing coherent development policies that benefit all regions challenging. Moreover, protests and demonstrations against conservative policies or actions could disrupt economic activities and discourage investment, further complicating efforts toward achieving balanced and inclusive development in Spain. Therefore, effectively managing the complexities of contentious politics while promoting sustainable and equitable development will be essential for Spain's future progress.


Spain has witnessed a surge in demonstrations rallying behind nationalism in recent elections.
Conclusion

The strengthening of conservative political structures in Spain's national political sphere reflects wider patterns of political polarization, dissatisfaction with established parties, and the resurgence of populist right-wing ideologies throughout Europe. Despite VOX facing setbacks in the recent 2023 elections with the re-election of Pedro Sánchez, a member of the Spanish Socialist Worker's Party, the capacity of VOX to exert influence remains formidable. The party's anti-establishment rhetoric, nationalist stance, and appeals to concerns regarding immigration, identity politics, and law enforcement have propelled its trajectory. Even as the prominence of a far-right agenda diminishes, its impact on the policy agenda and political environment within the conservative domain endures, potentially shaping government priorities and decision-making processes on a national scale.


Voicing their frustrations on the streets, conservative Spanish citizens rally for VOX during the recent election campaigns in 2023.

The 2023 Spanish parliamentary elections marked a significant turning point, with the progressive party prevailing over far-right VOX. This outcome highlights the endurance of democratic principles and the rejection of nationalist rhetoric by the Spanish electorate. It emphasizes the importance of protecting the autonomous recognition and rights of the Autonomous Communities across Spain, ensuring their voices and identities are respected within the national framework.


Moving forward, Spain must prioritize dialogue and cooperation to address societal divisions and uphold the autonomy of its diverse regions, encouraging a more cohesive and inclusive society for all citizens while maintaining national accordance to avoid a return to the suppression faced by its citizens during authoritarian control. Furthermore, the election results signal a mandate for policies that promote social cohesion, economic prosperity, and the protection of individual rights. As Spain confronts the challenges of its divided political environment, its political representatives and voting citizens must uphold democratic values and the rule of law to ensure a stable and prosperous future for future generations.

Bibliography

  1. Balfour, Rosa. "Dancing with Separatists: Can Spain's New Government Last?" Brookings, 18 March 2023. https://www.brookings.edu/articles/dancing-with-separatists-can-spains-new-government-last/

  2. García, Pablo. "Spain’s Future Politics Are Up for Grabs. What Happens Next?" The Guardian, 5 October 2023. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/oct/05/spain-future-politics-election-government

  3. O'Leary, Brendan. "What Vox and the Spanish Election Tell Us About the European Far-Right." UK in a Changing Europe, 10 November 2022.https://ukandeu.ac.uk/what-vox-and-the-spanish-election-tell-us-about-the-european-far-right/

  4. Sampedro, Víctor, and Lorenzo Mosca. "Digital Media, Contentious Politics and Party Systems in Italy and Spain." Javnost (Ljubljana, Slovenia) 25, no. 1–2 (2018): 160–168.

  5. Vacas-Martín, Sandra. "When Digital Platforms Become Content Moderators: An Analysis of Facebook’s Content Moderation Practices in Spain." International Journal of Communication 14 (2020): 3324-3343. https://ijoc.org/index.php/ijoc/article/viewFile/9056/3124

  6. Divita, David. "Radical-right Populism in Spain and the Strategy of Chronopolitics." Language in Society. Cambridge University Press, 12 September 2020. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/language-in-society/article/radicalright-populism-in-spain-and-the-strategy-of-chronopolitics/36C64A0DC2F0CF1D7A700FF957C9D599

Comments


bottom of page